In my early twenties, I joined a legalistic church. It felt right for me at the time because I was focused on performance. My identity depended on my successes and failures. When I succeeded, I got praise and felt good. When I messed up, I felt shame and regret; I wanted to hide. The church gave me rules to follow, and if I kept them, I felt good about myself and believed I was pleasing God.
I was proud that I kept the seventh-day Sabbath, observed all the Old Testament holidays, avoided Christmas and Easter, and followed the clean and unclean food laws. I read my Bible or other religious material every day. It made me feel good about myself, but looking back, I see I was self-righteous.
Understanding true grace has been a lifelong process. It began when the legalistic church started changing its doctrine under the influence of Hank Hanegraaff. The church began teaching about grace, and I started learning.
Grace
Grace means getting favor we don’t earn. In a world where everything is based on merit, grace is hard to accept. When we do well in school, we get good grades. I was the salutatorian in high school, and my hard work was rewarded with grades and a trophy. I ran Cross Country and Track. Working hard, practicing, and running fast led to trophies and a letterman jacket. At work, doing a good job brought praise, good reviews, and raises.
I have a merit-based mindset drilled into me by the world. Naturally, I felt I had to earn God’s favor. But God says I don’t have to earn it. It is freely given. That’s so hard to accept, especially when I fail.
At work, mistakes could be expensive. As a computer programmer, a mistake meant a bug in the code and something not working for a customer. I felt terrible when that happened, and it was my fault. Any mistake, big or small, made me feel bad about myself. I didn’t want to admit my errors and wanted to hide them.
When I struggled with lust, I felt a lot of shame. I knew it was wrong, but it felt good, and I became addicted. Admitting I needed help was the hardest part. I joined accountability groups, and what helped most was knowing everyone else was struggling too. It was easier to confess to people who understood.
These groups helped me learn about grace. When I messed up and admitted it, no one condemned me or told me to just try harder. Instead, they reminded me I was loved and forgiven.
Shame
When I failed or made mistakes, I saw myself as worthless. Those feelings didn’t push me away from failure—they pulled me toward it. Sinning felt good and gave me a high. When I felt worthless and ashamed, I wanted to feel good again, so I’d do the same thing that caused the shame. It was a vicious and insane cycle that kept repeating.
Willpower and discipline didn’t break the cycle. Love did. My accountability partners loved and accepted me as I was, and reminded me that God still loves me.
Those men gave me more than accountability; they gave me acceptance and love. Even though it felt natural to give that back, I realized I had spent most of my life closing myself off from receiving love.
Receiving Love
Giving has always come easily to me because there is reward in giving. Giving feels good and looks impressive to others. I love giving because it makes me feel good about myself. Paul said that Jesus said, “It is more blessed to give than receive (Acts 20:35).”
Receiving is hard for me. Because I don’t like myself and think I’m not worthy, I’ve shut myself off from receiving.
I’ve realized that my struggle to receive comes from shame—from not feeling accepted and feeling unworthy of people’s time and attention. Love changes that.
Before I met my wife, I tried to earn every woman’s love by trying to impress them. When it didn’t work, I blamed myself and felt even more shame.
I didn’t date my future wife. Instead, I courted her and asked her father’s permission first.
Instead of trying to win my wife’s heart, I trusted God to bring us together. I prayed during our first meeting, giving the relationship to God from the start. We met online and courted online for the first month. Our first date was a Bible Study. Not many women would want that as a first date, but the right one did. Together, we read 1 Corinthians 13 and looked at it this way: God is love, so how does God show each part of love?
I didn’t earn my wife’s love. She loved me with a love given by God (and her desire shall be for her husband; Genesis 3:16). My wife was, and still is, an example of God’s grace.
My wife helps break my shame by loving me. I didn’t earn her love; she chose to give it. That’s a picture of grace. I didn’t earn God’s love either. I receive it because He chose to give it to me.
My True Identity
My identity used to be based on my performance and how I saw myself. My accountability partners, my wife, and others have shown me a new identity. I am made in God’s image, His beloved son, and He is pleased with me. I didn’t earn His favor, love, or acceptance; it was given to me.
Living from this new identity doesn’t mean I have arrived. Shame still shows up. When I fail, the old voice says I’m worthless and should hide. But now there’s another voice, and it’s louder: You are loved. You belong. Come to me. (Matthew 11:28)
The legalistic church I joined in my twenties gave me a list to follow. If I kept the list, I felt good about myself. If I broke it, I felt ashamed. Back then, I didn’t know that God wasn’t interested in my list. He cared about me, not my performance or my record, but me.
I am made in the image of God. I am His beloved son—not because of what I’ve done or failed to do, but because He says so.
After spending my whole life trying to earn love, I’m still learning how to simply receive it.
